As a three-year starter in the rivalry, Garrett completed 65% of his passes that covered 470 yards. He grew 4 touchdown passes while rushing for 195 total yards, averaging 5.5 yards per carry and 1 touchdown. Garrett was also the starting kicker and punter in this rivalry, averaging 40 yards per punt. Garrett was a three-time All-Conference player, and in 2015 he was selected to the All-State team and USA All-West Virginia team. Garrett was also a two-time All-Conference and All-State basketball player. He currently plays basketball at VMI and is pursuing a degree in business and economics.