Tim played in the Rivalry in 2001, 2002, and 2003. As Captain of the 2003 team, Tim led the Wildcats to a thrilling 28-21 victory, capping an undefeated regular season. In the game, Tim carried the ball 22 times for 143 yards. He scored on runs of 18 yards, 14 yards, and caught a 20 yard pass for his 3rd score. Tim went on to have a great career for Brockport State University, earning 4 varsity letters for the Golden Eagles.