The Hall of Fame inductee from Colerain High School is Greg Tabar. Greg was a quarterback during his time at Colerain High School. He was a captain of the 2009 Colerain football team and played for two years in the Colerain-Elder rivalry in 2009 and 2010. Greg was awared the OHSAA Southwestern Ohio Scholar Athlete. Presenting his award is Marine Sergeant Thomas Combs.
The Hall of Fame inductee from Elder High School is Mark Miller. Elder defeated Colerain by a score of 20-7 in the 2009 season as Mark threw for 275 yards and 2 touchdowns, leading the Panthers to victory in front of 13,000 fans at the Pit. Mark went on to be selected as Player of the Year in Cincinnati for the second consecutive season. Currently, Mark plays football at Ohio Dominican University with a major in business.